Blog · Business · 19 November 2026 · 3 min read
I studied 1,190 coaches on YouTube. 7 in 10 send their viewers nowhere
I looked at 1,190 coaches who run a paid Skool group and post on YouTube. About 7 in 10 had no free lead magnet under their videos, and the ones who had one made more. Here's what I found, and what to put under your next video.

The short answer
Most coaches on YouTube don't put a free lead magnet under their videos. Of the 1,190 coaches I studied, all running a paid Skool group, about 7 in 10 of the ones still posting had none in their video descriptions from the last year. The coaches with one made about $2,400 a month from their group, against about $1,500 for those without. That's an estimate, and it doesn't prove the magnet caused it. Most of the magnets that do exist don't work either: about 1 in 12 has all five ingredients.
If you coach and you post on YouTube, you probably know your videos should lead somewhere. I wanted to know how many coaches actually do it. So I looked.
1,190 coaches. Every one of them sells a paid Skool group and links their own YouTube channel.
How many coaches put a lead magnet under their videos?
Not many. About 7 in 10 of the coaches still posting had no free lead magnet in their video descriptions from the last year.
The video ends and there's nothing to do next. No free thing, no next step. A dead end.
I counted it the generous way too. Even when a free Skool group or a Facebook group counts as a magnet, more than 2 in 3 had nothing.
Do coaches with a lead magnet make more money?
On average, yes. The coaches with a free magnet made about $2,400 a month from their group. Without one, about $1,500.

Two things to be straight about. The revenue is an estimate: each group's price times its listed members, assuming half of them pay. And it's a pattern, not proof. The magnet might bring in the money, or the coaches who already make money might be the ones who bother building a magnet.
The pattern holds as earnings go up, though. About 1 in 6 coaches making under $1,000 a month had a magnet. Over $20,000 a month, it was 1 in 3.

Why don't most lead magnets work?
Having a magnet is one thing. Having one that works is rarer. I read 449 magnets from 280 coaches and checked each one for five ingredients. About 1 in 12 had all five.
The most common format was the weakest. A quarter of the magnets were PDFs, and not one of those passed. Fewer than a third named a next step at all.

What are the five ingredients of a lead magnet that works?
Here's what I checked every magnet for.
| Ingredient | What it means |
|---|---|
| You act on it | The person does something with it: works through steps, uses a tool, builds something. Reading on its own doesn't count. |
| Outcome over email | The page says what you get. It doesn't read like a box to collect an email. |
| One clear outcome | It promises one specific result, not a topic or a bundle of tips. |
| Names a next step | The page says what comes after: a call, a community, a paid offer. |
| Engages beyond reading | It's something you use, watch or interact with, not only text. |
The ingredient most magnets missed was one clear outcome. Most of them promise a topic. The ones that work promise a result.
What should a coach put under their next video?
A money magnet. That's what I call a free tool, prompt or quiz that solves the whole problem from the video.
When I say the whole problem, I mean all of your expertise, all of your knowledge, all of how you'd actually solve that problem for the person. In its entirety. For free.
That sounds like giving too much away. It isn't. The best free thing I've put under a video is my Viewer to Client Workbook. It takes someone from the idea for a video all the way to taking money from a client. I've paid people tens of thousands of dollars for what's in it. The only thing it asks of you is the time to work through it.
Tools did better than documents in the study too. 4 of the 42 tool magnets passed. None of the 114 PDFs did.
Where should the magnet go?
Under every video. Put it in the first line of the description, so it shows before anyone taps more. Pin it as the first comment. Say it out loud in the video, and put a QR code on screen for the people watching on a TV.
Questions people ask
What is a lead magnet for a coach?
A free thing you give away that solves part of the problem you coach, usually in exchange for an email. The best ones solve the whole problem from one video and say what comes next.
Are PDF lead magnets worth it?
In my study, no. A quarter of the magnets were PDFs and none of them had all five ingredients. A tool, a prompt or a quiz did far better.
Do I need a big YouTube channel for a lead magnet to work?
No. In my study the biggest channels, 250,000 subscribers and up, were the least likely to name a next step: 9% did, against 36% of channels under 10,000 subscribers.
How do I know if my lead magnet is any good?
Check it against the five ingredients above. If it's missing one, the fix is often a line of copy: say the one result it gets, and say what happens next.
Where the numbers come from
- My study of 1,190 coaches, consultants and education creators who run a paid, recurring Skool group and link their own YouTube channel. Snapshot 5 October 2026, from the last 50 uploads in the last 12 months of each channel. It checks video descriptions only, not channel links, pinned comments or bios.
- Revenue is estimated from each group's list price times its listed members, assuming half of them pay. It shows a pattern, not cause.
- Magnet quality: 449 magnets from 280 coaches, each checked for the five ingredients, with a sample checked again by hand.